COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF TECHNICAL AND OPERATIONAL CHARACTERISTICS OF CHISEL PLOWS AND SUBSOILERS FOR ANTI-EROSION SOIL TILLAGE
https://doi.org/10.53360/2788-7995-2026-3(23)-32
Abstract
The paper presents a comparative analysis of technical and operational characteristics of modern chisel plows and subsoilers used for non-inversion anti-erosion soil tillage. The relevance is determined by the high level of wind erosion in Northern Kazakhstan, where over 52 million hectares are subject to erosion. The aim of work is to conduct a comparative analysis of the technical and operational characteristics of modern chisel plows and sweep subsoilers for anti-erosion tillage. For comparative analysis, nine implements were selected, divided into two groups: chisel plows (PChM-4, PCh-4-5, PCh-4.5PM, KAMA TIGER 3, Dondi 813) and sweep subsoilers (RSP-5.4, Cultiplow Platinum SR Agrisem, STAVR PG-5, STAVR PG-7). The official test protocols of accredited MTS for 2014-2025 served as the information base. The comparison methodology was based on the requirements of GOST 20915-2011, GOST 33736- 2016, GOST 52777-2007 and GOST 24088-88. The analysis was carried out according to qualitative and technical and operational indicators. Chisel plows provided soil crumbling of 90.6-98.6%, while for sweep subsoilers this indicator was 49.9-94.9% (RSP-5.4 – 62.3-68.4%). The best stubble retention was achieved by STAVR PG-5 (89.0%); chisel plows meet the standard of ≥60% but are inferior to sweep subsoilers, which is critical for anti-erosion technologies. Among chisel plows, PCh-4.5PM showed the highest working capacity (5.14-5.22 ha/h); among subsoilers, Dondi 813 led (5.43 ha/h). The lowest specific fuel consumption was recorded for PChM-4 (14.62 kg/ha), the highest for RSP-5.4 (21.36 kg/ha). Based on the overall set of indicators, PCh-4.5PM and PChM-4 are recommended for the conditions of Northern Kazakhstan; under the threat of wind erosion, STAVR PG-5 is preferable, and for compacted soils, RSP-5.4.
About the Authors
A. B. ShayakhmetovKazakhstan
Amangeldy Bulatovich Shayakhmetov – Candidate of Technical Sciences, Associate Professor Department of Agro-engineering, Mechanics, and Metalworking
010011, Republic of Kazakhstan, Astana, 62 Zhenis Avenue
T. V. Bedych
Kazakhstan
Tatyana Vitalievna Bedych – Candidate of Technical Sciences, Associate Professor of the Department of Energy and Mechanical Engineering
010011, Republic of Kazakhstan, Astana, 62 Zhenis Avenue
M. A. Amantayev
Kazakhstan
Maxat Amantayuly Amantayev – PhD, Associate Professor of the Department of Agricultural Machinery and Transport
110000, Republic of Kazakhstan, Kostanay, 47 Baitursynov Street
R. Gabdyssalyk
Kazakhstan
Riza Gabdyssalyk – PhD, Associate Professor of the Postgraduate Sector
070004, Republic of Kazakhstan, Ust-Kamenogorsk, 19 Serikbayev Street
A. Sugirbay
Kazakhstan
Adilet Sugirbay – PhD, Head of the Design Bureau, Research School of Veterinary Medicine and Agriculture
071400, Republic of Kazakhstan, Semey, 163 Shugaev Street
References
1. Kashtanov A.N. Pochvozashchitnoe zemledelie / A.N. Kashtanov, M.N. Zaslavskii. – Moskva: Kolos, 2004. – 447 s. (in Russian).
2. Baraev A.I. Pochvozashchitnaya sistema zemledeliya / A.I. Baraev. – Alma-Ata: Kainar, 1975. – 304 s. (in Russian).
3. No-till in northern, western and south-western Europe: A review of problems and opportunities for crop production and the environment / B.D. Soane et al // Soil and Tillage Research, 2012. – Vol. 118. – P. 66-87. (in English).
4. Munkholm L.J. Soil pore characteristics assessed from X-ray micro-CT derived images and correlations to soil friability / L.J. Munkholm, R.J. Heck, B. Deen // Geoderma, 2012. – Vol. 181-182. – P. 22-29. (in English).
5. Innovations in agronomy for food legumes. A review / K.H.M. Siddique et al // Agronomy for Sustainable Development, 2012. – Vol. 32. – P. 45-64. (in English).
6. Kertész Á. Conservation agriculture in Europe / Á. Kertész, B. Madarász // International Soil and Water Conservation Research. – 2014. – Vol. 2(1). – P. 91-96. (in English).
7. Ogbeche O.S. Development and performance evaluation of instrumented subsoilers in breaking soil hard-pan / O.S. Ogbeche, M.S. Idowu, E. Theophilus // AgricEngInt. CIGR Journal. – 2018. – Vol. 20, № 3 – P. 85-96. (in English).
8. Blednykh V.V. Teoriya pochvoobrabatyvayushchego klina i ee prilozheniya: monografiya / V.V. Blednykh. – Chelyabinsk: CHGAA, 2013. – 90 s. (in Russian).
9. Kuvaev A.N. Obosnovanie parametrov orudiya dlya osnovnoi obrabotki uplotnennykh pochv k traktoru tyagovogo klassa 6 / A.N. Kuvaev. – Kostanai: NAO «Kostanaiskii regional'nyi universitet imeni A.Baitursynova», 2022. – 179 c. (in Russian).
10. Analiz konstruktsii i tekhnologicheskikh parametrov chizel'nykh plugov i glubokorykhlitelei / S.V. Malyukov i dr. // Izvestiya NV AUK, 2024. – № 3(75). – S. 412-422. (in Russian).
11. Protokol ispytanii № 11-41-14 (4010082). Plug chizel'nyi PCHM-4 // FGBU «SeveroKavkazskaya MIS». – Zernograd, 2014. – 16 s. (in Russian).
12. Protokol ispytanii № 12-20-2019 (5010182). Plug chizel'nyi PCh-4-5 // FGBU «Sibirskaya MIS». – Sosnovskoe, 2019. – 4 s. (in Russian).
13. Protokol ispytanii № 07-18-2025. Plug chizel'nyi PCh-4,5PM // FGBU «Kubanskaya MIS». – Novokubansk, 2025. – 9 s. (in Russian).
14. Protokol ispytanii № 07-21-2023. Glubokorykhlitel' KAMA TIGER 3 // FGBU «Kubanskaya MIS». – Novokubansk, 2023. – 11 s. (in Russian).
15. Protokol ispytanii № 07-110-2016 (6240472). Glubokorykhlitel' Dondi 813 // FGBU «Kubanskaya MIS». – Novokubansk, 2016. – 30 s. (in Russian).
16. Protokol ispytanii № 07-95-2020 (6240722). Glubokorykhlitel' Cultiplow Platinum SR Agrisem // FGBU «Kubanskaya MIS». – Novokubansk, 2020. – 5 s. (in Russian).
17. Reshenie Komissii po protokolu 01-42-22. Ploskorez-glubokorykhlitel' STAVR PG-5 // AO «Rubtsovskii zavod zapasnykh chastei». – Altaiskaya MIS, 2022. (in Russian).
18. Reshenie Komissii po protokolu 01-42-22. Ploskorez-glubokorykhlitel' STAVR PG-7 // AO «Rubtsovskii zavod zapasnykh chastei». – Altaiskaya MIS, 2022. (in Russian).
19. Naznachenie i oblast' primeneniya kombinirovannogo orudiya-glubokorykhlitelya / S.K. Toigambaev i dr. // Agroprodovol'stvennaya ehkonomika, 2023. – № 4. – S. 23-29. (in Russian).
20. Snizhenie tyagovogo soprotivleniya chizel'nykh orudii / D.S. Gapich i dr. // Izvestiya NV AUK, 2023. – № 4(72). – S. 398-409. (in Russian).
Review
For citations:
Shayakhmetov A.B., Bedych T.V., Amantayev M.A., Gabdyssalyk R., Sugirbay A. COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF TECHNICAL AND OPERATIONAL CHARACTERISTICS OF CHISEL PLOWS AND SUBSOILERS FOR ANTI-EROSION SOIL TILLAGE. Bulletin of Shakarim University. Technical Sciences. 2026;(3(23)):343-351. https://doi.org/10.53360/2788-7995-2026-3(23)-32
JATS XML















