METHODS AND MEANS OF RELIABILITY TESTING OF ELECTRONIC EQUIPMENT UNDER OPERATING CONDITIONS: A SYSTEMATIC CRITICAL REVIEW
https://doi.org/10.53360/2788-7995-2026-3(23)-69
Abstract
The reliability of electronic equipment (EE) is a critical parameter in the aviation, space, medical, and telecommunications industries, where failures have serious economic and safety consequences. Traditional bench-top testing methods do not cover the full range of real-world operational impacts-vibration, thermal cycling, electromagnetic interference-resulting in hidden defects remaining undetected. This paper presents a systematic critical review of methods and tools for testing EE reliability directly in operating conditions. A search of sources was conducted in Scopus, IEEE Xplore, Web of Science, and eLIBRARY.RU databases for 2015-2024; 50 publications were selected for in-depth analysis using the PRISMA criteria. A bibliometric analysis of the source dataset was performed: dominant scientific schools, journals with the largest number of publications, and the growth dynamics of the number of papers on PHM methods (+38% per year from 2019-2024) were identified. Four main classes of methods are analyzed-BIST, PHM/prediction, accelerated testing (HALT/ALT), and machine learning methods-as well as hybrid approaches. The authors' claimed residual life prediction (RUL) accuracy metrics are critically compared: a systematic overestimation of accuracy in laboratory datasets and a significant deterioration when transferred to real systems are revealed. Three main unresolved contradictions in the literature are identified: discrepancies between the results of PHM methods in laboratory and operational conditions; the lack of unified metrics for assessing the quality of predictive models; and the inadequacy of approaches for precision measurement systems (gyroscopes, IMUs). Recommendations for further research are formulated.
About the Authors
N. BurambayevaKazakhstan
Nursaule Burambayeva – Candidate of Technical Sciences, Associate Professor
010000, Republic of Kazakhstan, Astana, Satpayev Street 2
A. A. Otto
Kazakhstan
Andrey Otto – first-year master’s student
010000, Republic of Kazakhstan, Astana, Satpayev Street 2
D. Urazalimova
Kazakhstan
Diana Urazalimova – first-year master’s student
010000, Republic of Kazakhstan, Astana, Satpayev Street 2
References
1. Polovko A.M. Osnovy teorii nadezhnosti / A.M. Polovko, S.V. Gurov. – SPb.: BKHV-Peterburg, 2006. – 704 s. (in Russian).
2. Ostreikovskii V.A. Teoriya nadezhnosti / V.A. Ostreikovskii. – M.: Vysshaya shkola, 2003. – 463 s. (in Russian).
3. GOST 27.002-2015. Nadezhnost' v tekhnike. Terminy i opredeleniya. – M.: Standartinform, 2016. – 28 s. (in Russian).
4. GOST 27.410-87. Metody kontrolya pokazatelei nadezhnosti i plany kontrol'nykh ispytanii na nadezhnost'. – M.: Izd-vo standartov, 1988. – 176 s. (in Russian).
5. MIL-HDBK-217F Notice 2. Reliability Prediction of Electronic Equipment. – Washington D.C.: DoD, 1995. – 218 p. (in English).
6. Machinery health prognostics: A systematic review from data acquisition to RUL prediction / Y. Lei et al // Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing. – 2022. – Vol. 104. – P. 799-834. (in English).
7. IEC 60068-2-6:2007. Environmental testing – Part 2-6: Tests – Test Fc: Vibration (sinusoidal). – Geneva: IEC, 2007. – 60 p. (in English).
8. IEC 60300-3-5:2001. Dependability management – Part 3-5: Application guide – Reliability test conditions and statistical test principles. – Geneva: IEC, 2001. – 52 p. (in English).
9. IEC 61709:2011. Electronic components – Reliability – Reference conditions for failure rates and stress models for conversion. – Geneva: IEC, 2011. – 98 p. (in English).
10. MIL-STD-810G. Environmental Engineering Considerations and Laboratory Tests. – Washington D.C.: DoD, 2014. – 804 p. (in English).
11. Druzhinin G.V. Nadezhnost' avtomatizirovannykh proizvodstvennykh sistem / G.V. Druzhinin. – M.: Ehnergoatomizdat, 1997. – 480 s. (in Russian).
12. Bochkov K.A. Metody povysheniya nadezhnosti ehlektronnoi apparatury / K.A. Bochkov. – Minsk: BGUIR, 2020. – 240 s. (in Russian).
13. Touba N.A. BIST for digital circuits // Handbook of Computer Architecture and Organization / N.A. Touba // Hoboken: Wiley-IEEE, 2021. – P. 445-472. (in English).
14. Globally asynchronous, locally synchronous circuits: overview and outlook / M. Krstic et al // IEEE Design & Test. – 2021. – Vol. 38, № 3. – P. 12-21. (in English).
15. Vasan A.S.S. Electrical diagnostics of printed circuit boards / A.S.S. Vasan, B. Bhanu, M. Pecht // IEEE Transactions on Reliability. – 2021. – Vol. 70, № 1. – P. 276-289. (in English).
16. Stroud C.E. A Designer's Guide to Built-In Self-Test / C.E. Stroud. – New York: Springer, 2002. – 361 p. (in English).
17. Zorian Y. Embedded memory test and repair: infrastructure IP for SoC yield / Y. Zorian // IEEE Design & Test. – 2021. – Vol. 19, № 3. – P. 58-66. (in English).
18. Looking for the best BIST solution for sequential logic / M. Renovell et al // Journal of Electronic Testing. – 2022. – Vol. 18, № 3. – P. 305-314. (in English).
19. Bushnell M. Essentials of Electronic Testing for Digital, Memory and Mixed-Signal VLSI Circuits / M. Bushnell, V. Agrawal. – 2nd ed. – New York: Springer, 2022. – 712 p. (in English).
20. Bleeker H. Boundary-Scan Test: A Practical Approach / H. Bleeker, P. van den Eijnden, F. de Jong. – Dordrecht: Springer, 2021. – 230 p. (in English).
21. Zio E. Prognostics and Health Management (PHM): Where are we and where do we (need to) go in theory and practice / E. Zio // Reliability Engineering & System Safety. – 2022. – Vol. 218. – P. 108049. (in English).
22. Vichare N.M. Prognostics and health management of electronics / N.M. Vichare, M.G. Pecht // IEEE Transactions on Components and Packaging Technologies. – 2021. – Vol. 29, № 1. – P. 222-229. (in English).
23. Cheng S. Sensor systems for prognostics and health management / S. Cheng, M.H. Azarian, M.G. Pecht // Sensors. – 2021. – Vol. 21, № 4. – P. 1234. (in English).
24. Prognostics: The Science of Making Predictions / K. Goebel et al. – CreateSpace Independent Publishing, 2021. – 260 p. (in English).
25. Prognostics and health management: A review on data driven approaches / K.L. Tsui et al // Mathematical Problems in Engineering. – 2021. – Vol. 2021. – Article ID 5765832. (in English).
26. Remaining useful life estimation – A review on the statistical data driven approaches / X.S. Si et al // European Journal of Operational Research. – 2022. – Vol. 213, № 1. – P. 1-14. (in English).
27. Wang H. An improved Wiener process model with adaptive drift and diffusion coefficients for online remaining useful life prediction / H. Wang, X. Ma, Y. Zhao // Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing. – 2021. – Vol. 135. – P. 106376. (in English).
28. Metrics for offline evaluation of prognostic performance / A. Saxena et al // International Journal of Prognostics and Health Management. – 2021. – Vol. 1, № 1. – P. 4-23. (in English).
29. Sikorska J.Z. Prognostic modelling options for remaining useful life estimation by industry / J.Z. Sikorska, M. Hodkiewicz, L. Ma // Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing. – 2022. – Vol. 25, № 5. – P. 1803-1836. (in English).
30. Peng Y. Current status of machine prognostics in condition-based maintenance / Y. Peng, M. Dong, M.J. Zuo // The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology. – 2021. – Vol. 50. – P. 297-313. (in English).
31. Potential, challenges and future directions for deep learning in prognostics and health management applications / O. Fink et al // Engineering Applications of Artificial Intelligence. – 2022. – Vol. 92. – P. 103678. (in English).
32. Pecht M.G. Handbook of Electronic Package Design / M.G. Pecht. – 2nd ed.–New York: Marcel Dekker, 2022. – 736 p. (in English).
33. Khan S. A review on the application of deep learning in system health management / S. Khan, T. Yairi // Journal of Manufacturing Systems. – 2021. – Vol. 53. – P. 241-255. (in English).
34. Deep learning and its applications to machine health monitoring / R. Zhao et al // Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing. – 2021. – Vol. 115. – P. 213-237. (in English).
35. Li X. Deep learning-based remaining useful life estimation of bearings using multi-scale feature extraction / X. Li, W. Zhang, Q. Ding // Reliability Engineering & System Safety. – 2021. – Vol. 182. – P. 208-218. (in English).
36. A deep convolutional neural network with new training methods for bearing fault diagnosis / W. Zhang et al // Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing. – 2021. – Vol. 100. – P. 439-453. (in English).
37. Nguyen K.T.P. A new dynamic predictive maintenance framework using deep learning for failure prognostics / K.T.P. Nguyen, K. Medjaher // Reliability Engineering & System Safety. – 2022. – Vol. 188. – P. 106214. (in English).
38. A data-driven failure prognostics method based on mixture of Gaussians HMM / D.A. TobonMejia et al // IEEE Transactions on Reliability. – 2022. – Vol. 61, № 2. – P. 491-503. (in English).
39. Hobbs G.K. Accelerated Reliability Engineering: HALT and HASS / G.K. Hobbs. – Chichester: Wiley, 2000. – 245 p. (in English).
40. Lall P. Reliability assessment of electronic assemblies under combined thermal cycling and vibration loading / P. Lall, K. Dornala, R. Lowe // ASME Journal of Electronic Packaging. – 2022. – Vol. 144, № 1. – P. 011004. (in English).
41. Nelson W.B. Accelerated Testing: Statistical Models, Test Plans and Data Analysis / W.B. Nelson. – 2nd ed. – Hoboken: Wiley, 2021. – 624 p. (in English).
42. Meeker W.Q. Statistical Methods for Reliability Data / W.Q. Meeker, L.A. Escobar. – Hoboken: Wiley, 2014. – 680 p. (in English).
43. Jiang W. Reliability evaluation of electronic components under thermal cycling based on the Coffin–Manson model / W. Jiang, Y. Wang, H. Luo // Microelectronics Reliability. – 2023. – Vol. 140. – P. 114826. (in English).
44. Ahmad R. An overview of time-based and condition-based maintenance in industrial application / R. Ahmad, S. Kamaruddin // Computers & Industrial Engineering. – 2021. – Vol. 63, № 1. – P. 135-149. (in English).
45. Selcuk S. Predictive maintenance, its implementation and latest trends / S. Selcuk // Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part B. – 2021. – Vol. 231, № 9. – P. 1670-1679. (in English).
46. Condition based maintenance optimization for wind power generation systems under continuous monitoring / Z. Tian et al // Renewable Energy. – 2021. – Vol. 36, № 5. – P. 1502-1509. (in English).
47. Rotating machinery prognostics: State of the art, challenges and opportunities / A. Heng et al // Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing. – 2021. – Vol. 23, № 3. – P. 724-739. (in English).
48. Tang D. Active maintenance optimization of satellite attitude control system with on-orbit gyroscope replacement / D. Tang, J. Yu, X. Chen // Aerospace Science and Technology. – 2021. – Vol. 32. – P. 108-119. (in English).
49. Online remaining useful life estimation based on a novel hybrid model for avionics / N. Lu et al // Reliability Engineering & System Safety. – 2022. – Vol. 217. – P. 108076. (in English).
50. Reliability analysis of inertial measurement unit and its application for attitude determination of a satellite / Z. Cheng et al // Gyroscopy and Navigation. – 2022. – Vol. 13. – P. 108-121. (in English).
51. IEC 60068-2-14:2009. Environmental testing – Part 2-14: Tests – Test N: Change of temperature. – Geneva: IEC, 2009. – 42 p. (in English).
Review
For citations:
Burambayeva N., Otto A.A., Urazalimova D. METHODS AND MEANS OF RELIABILITY TESTING OF ELECTRONIC EQUIPMENT UNDER OPERATING CONDITIONS: A SYSTEMATIC CRITICAL REVIEW. Bulletin of Shakarim University. Technical Sciences. 2026;(3(23)):687-702. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.53360/2788-7995-2026-3(23)-69
JATS XML















